Tapia Syndrome
Overview
Tapia syndrome (also known as Tapia's syndrome or combined CN X-XII palsy) is a rare cranial nerve syndrome characterized by unilateral paralysis of the tongue (hypoglossal nerve, CN XII) and unilateral laryngeal paralysis (vagus nerve, CN X, specifically the recurrent laryngeal nerve branch).[1] The syndrome results from extracranial lesions affecting both nerves as they course in close proximity in the upper neck, typically at the level of the posterior pharynx or retroparotid space.[2]
The syndrome is most commonly seen as a complication of general anesthesia and endotracheal intubation, particularly following prolonged or difficult airway management.[3] Other causes include trauma, tumors, and vascular lesions in the retroparotid space. The characteristic presentation includes ipsilateral tongue deviation on protrusion (toward the affected side) and ipsilateral vocal fold paralysis.[4]
Epidemiology
A 2022 systematic review of 65 patients with Tapia syndrome provides the most comprehensive epidemiologic data available:[5]
Demographics:
- Male:Female ratio: 2.3:1
- Mean age: 44 ± 17.5 years (range: 15-95 years)
- Laterality: Left-sided predominance (60%) with a 3:2 left:right ratio
- The left-sided predominance may relate to anatomical factors or positioning during intubation
Etiology distribution (peripheral causes):
- Postintubation edema: 77% (most common modern cause)
- Extrinsic compression: 15%
- Vascular disease: 3%
- Other/not defined: 5%
- Central causes: Only 2 cases (3%) - Tapia syndrome is overwhelmingly a peripheral, iatrogenic condition in modern practice[5]
History
Antonio García Tapia (1875-1950) was a prominent Spanish otolaryngologist born on May 22, 1875, in Ayllón, Segovia.[6] He received his doctorate from the University of Madrid in 1896 and subsequently trained in otolaryngology at several European centers including Paris, Freiburg, Berlin, and Vienna under noted specialists including Marcel Lermoyez and Gustav Killian.[7]
García Tapia first described this syndrome in 1904[8] after observing a patient with combined vocal fold and tongue paralysis following a penetrating bullet wound to the neck. The syndrome was initially described in the context of penetrating trauma, but in modern practice it is more commonly encountered as a complication of general anesthesia and airway management. Reports following intubation first appeared in the mid-20th century, and the syndrome is now recognized as a significant potential complication of airway manipulation and various head and neck procedures.[2]
Pathophysiology
Relevant Anatomy
Anatomical basis for combined CN X and XII involvement:
Understanding the extracranial course of these nerves explains the anatomical vulnerability to injury.[1] The critical anatomical relationship is that both the vagus nerve (CN X, specifically its recurrent laryngeal branch) and the hypoglossal nerve (CN XII) course in close proximity within the retroparotid and retropharyngeal spaces of the neck.
Hypoglossal nerve (CN XII):
- Exits skull through hypoglossal canal (medial to jugular foramen)
- Descends between internal carotid artery and internal jugular vein
- Loops around occipital artery
- Passes lateral to external carotid artery
- Crosses lingual artery
- Enters tongue deep to mylohyoid muscle
- Motor innervation to intrinsic and most extrinsic tongue muscles
Vagus nerve (CN X) and recurrent laryngeal nerve:
- Vagus nerve exits skull through jugular foramen
- Descends in carotid sheath between ICA/CCA and IJV
- Recurrent laryngeal nerve branch:
- Right: Loops under subclavian artery
- Left: Loops under aortic arch
- Both ascend in tracheoesophageal groove
- Motor innervation to all intrinsic laryngeal muscles (except cricothyroid - supplied by superior laryngeal nerve)
Site of combined vulnerability: The retroparotid/retropharyngeal space is the critical site where CN X (or its branches) and CN XII course in close proximity:[3]
- Located at base of skull below hypoglossal canal and jugular foramen
- Posterior pharyngeal region
- Lateral to pharyngeal wall
- Adjacent to oropharynx junction and hypopharynx
Mechanism of injury during intubation:
- Compression against greater cornu of hyoid bone
- Compression against transverse processes of C1/C2 vertebrae
- Pressure from inflated endotracheal tube cuff
- Direct compression or stretch from laryngoscope blade
- Nerve stretching with excessive neck hyperextension or rotation
- Proposed mechanism: neuropraxia (compression-type injury) rather than axonotmesis[1]
Disease Etiology
Tapia syndrome results from lesions affecting both the vagus nerve (CN X) and hypoglossal nerve (CN XII) as they course through the extracranial cervical region. The vast majority of modern cases are iatrogenic in origin, related to airway manipulation during anesthesia.[3]
Iatrogenic causes (most common):[1]
- Endotracheal intubation (direct compression - most frequent cause)
- Laryngeal mask airway (LMA) placement
- Overinflated endotracheal tube cuff
- Difficult or prolonged intubation requiring multiple attempts
- Patient positioning during surgery (neck hyperextension, rotation, lateral flexion)
- Nasogastric tube insertion
- Transoral procedures
Surgical procedures associated with Tapia syndrome:
- Rhinoplasty
- Septoplasty
- Cardiac surgery (median sternotomy positioning)
- Shoulder surgery (interscalene block or positioning)
- Thyroidectomy
- Cervical spine surgery
- Oral and maxillofacial surgery
- Retrosigmoid craniotomy (rare)
Traumatic etiologies:
- Penetrating neck trauma (original description by García Tapia, bullet wounds)
- Blunt neck trauma
- Fractures (skull base, cervical spine)
- Stretching or contusion of nerves
Neoplastic etiologies:
- Primary tumors of the retroparotid space
- Skull base tumors
- Metastatic disease to neck lymph nodes
- Tumor-related nerve compression or invasion
Vascular etiologies:
- Carotid artery dissection
- Carotid aneurysm
- Jugular vein thrombosis
- Vascular compression syndromes
Infectious/Inflammatory etiologies:
- Deep neck space infection (rare)
- Skull base osteomyelitis
- Tuberculosis (historical cause)
- Inflammatory conditions
Diagnosis
Tapia syndrome is a clinical diagnosis made principally upon clinical grounds based on the characteristic combination of unilateral hypoglossal and recurrent laryngeal nerve palsy in the setting of appropriate etiology (most commonly post-intubation).[1]
Patient History
Typical presentation context:
Timing of symptom onset:
- Symptoms typically noted upon awakening from anesthesia or in immediate post-operative period
- May be masked initially by residual sedation and anesthesia
- Onset in ICU patients may be more subtle, attributed initially to other post-intubation changes
Speech and voice symptoms:
- Dysarthria: Difficulty with articulation, especially lingual consonants (t, d, l, n)
- Dysphonia: Hoarse, breathy, weak voice quality
- Vocal fatigue: Voice quality worsens with prolonged speaking
Swallowing difficulties:
- Dysphagia: Difficulty with bolus manipulation, especially with lingual manipulation phase
- Aspiration: Coughing or choking with eating and drinking
- Difficulty with liquids vs. solids (tongue dysfunction impairs oral control)
- Residual food in mouth after swallowing
Tongue-specific symptoms:
- Difficulty moving tongue to sides and back
- Food accumulation in mouth (particularly on affected side)
- Slurred or unclear speech
- Difficulty with tongue-dependent tasks (licking lips, clearing mouth)
Anesthetic history clues:[4]
- Difficult intubation or prolonged intubation attempts
- Prolonged or complex surgery
- Excessive neck manipulation or positioning
- Multiple intubation attempts
- Overinflation of endotracheal tube cuff (reported by anesthesiologist)
Physical Examination
The characteristic physical examination findings in Tapia syndrome reveal the distinctive pattern of ipsilateral CN XII and CN X (recurrent laryngeal nerve) involvement.
Hypoglossal nerve (CN XII) examination:
- Tongue at rest: May show fasciculations or fibrillations (indicating lower motor neuron lesion)
- Tongue protrusion: Deviates TOWARD affected side (paralyzed side cannot generate sufficient force to push midline)
- Tongue bulk: Subtle atrophy may develop in chronic cases (weeks to months)
- Tongue strength: Weakness when pushing against cheek on affected side; patient cannot move weak side tongue tip laterally
- Tongue sensation: Normal (lingual nerve intact, providing sensory innervation)
Vagus nerve (CN X) examination:
- Voice quality: Hoarse, breathy, weak (characteristic of unilateral vocal fold paralysis)
- Phonation: Difficulty producing sustained phonation; voice breaks or becomes breathy
- Palate elevation: Normal (if only recurrent laryngeal nerve involved, vagus motor innervation to soft palate is spared via pharyngeal plexus)
- Gag reflex: Normal or intact (glossopharyngeal nerve and pharyngeal branches of vagus preserved)
- Cough: May be weak or ineffective (loss of vocal fold closure for pressure generation)
Laryngoscopy findings:
- Ipsilateral vocal cord or vocal fold paralysis
- Vocal fold typically in paramedian or paramedian-to-median position (characteristic of RLN palsy)
- Glottic insufficiency (inability to achieve complete midline closure)
- Reduced vocal fold mobility on affected side
- May show slight posterior commissure widening due to incomplete closure
Distinguishing features of Tapia syndrome:
- Ipsilateral tongue deviation TO affected side (CN XII lower motor neuron palsy)
- Ipsilateral vocal fold paralysis on SAME side (CN X/recurrent laryngeal nerve palsy)
- NO palatal weakness or asymmetry (superior laryngeal nerve and pharyngeal branches of vagus spared - key distinguishing feature)
- Normal gag reflex and pharyngeal function (CN IX and CN X pharyngeal branches intact)
- This preserved palatal function distinguishes Tapia from Collet-Sicard, Villaret, and Jackson syndromes[1]
Laboratory Tests
Laboratory testing generally not helpful for diagnosis but may be indicated based on suspected etiology:
- CBC, inflammatory markers (if infection suspected)
- Coagulation studies (if vascular)
- Imaging-directed workup
Imaging
Imaging in suspected Tapia syndrome is primarily directed toward excluding structural causes, particularly in non-iatrogenic presentations.
MRI of skull base and neck (with gadolinium contrast):[9]
- Evaluate for structural lesion (tumor, mass effect)
- Assess skull base pathology
- Identify retropharyngeal or parapharyngeal masses
- Detect vascular lesions (dissection, aneurysm, thrombosis)
- Note: Often entirely normal in post-intubation/iatrogenic cases, as nerve injury is typically due to compression rather than structural pathology[1]
- Preferred imaging modality for excluding structural etiologies
CT of neck (with contrast):
- Useful for rapid evaluation in acute trauma
- Rule out structural causes (masses, fractures)
- Evaluate for deep neck space infection or collection
- May be more readily available than MRI in emergency settings
Flexible laryngoscopy and strobolaryngoscopy:
- Critical diagnostic tool - directly visualizes vocal fold paralysis
- Confirms unilateral vocal fold paralysis in paramedian position
- Assesses vocal fold movement (complete paralysis vs. paresis)
- Evaluates glottic closure pattern and degree of insufficiency
- Stroboscopy assesses vibratory characteristics
Electromyography (EMG):[1]
- May help confirm nerve injury and localize lesion
- Provides prognostic value for expected recovery
- Identifies denervation changes and reinnervation
- Timing: Typically performed 2-4 weeks after injury (allows time for fibrillation potentials to develop)
- Bilateral EMG may be performed to assess CN XII and recurrent laryngeal nerve function
- Can differentiate neuropraxia from axonotmesis based on motor unit action potentials
Differential Diagnosis
The key to differentiating Tapia syndrome from other cranial nerve syndromes is the specific combination of CN X (recurrent laryngeal nerve) and CN XII involvement with preserved CN IX and normal palatal function.[1]
Related cranial nerve syndromes affecting larynx and tongue:
- Jackson syndrome
- Cranial nerves affected: CN X, XI, XII
- Location of lesion: Medulla oblongata or medullary region (intracranial)
- Key distinction: Intracranial lesion; includes CN XI (accessory nerve); palatal weakness present
- Clinical features: Vocal fold paralysis + tongue paralysis + weakness of trapezius/sternocleidomastoid
- Collet-Sicard syndrome
- Cranial nerves affected: CN IX, X, XI, XII
- Location of lesion: Jugular foramen and hypoglossal canal region (skull base)
- Key distinction: Includes CN IX (glossopharyngeal - affects gag reflex); involves both jugular foramen AND hypoglossal canal
- Clinical features: Vocal fold paralysis + tongue paralysis + loss of gag reflex + pharyngeal weakness
- Villaret syndrome
- Cranial nerves affected: CN IX, X, XI, XII + Horner syndrome
- Location of lesion: Retroparotid space (extracranial)
- Key distinction: Collet-Sicard syndrome (CN IX-XII palsy) PLUS ipsilateral Horner syndrome (sympathetic involvement)
- Clinical features: Vocal fold + tongue + gag reflex loss + ptosis + miosis + anhidrosis
- Schmidt syndrome
- Cranial nerves affected: CN X, XI only (spares CN XII)
- Location of lesion: Medulla or jugular foramen
- Key distinction: NO tongue involvement; vocal fold paralysis + trapezius/SCM weakness
- Vernet syndrome
- Cranial nerves affected: CN IX, X, XI only
- Location of lesion: Intracranial, within jugular foramen
- Key distinction: NO CN XII involvement; location always intracranial
Other differential considerations:
- Isolated vocal fold paralysis
- Causes: Thyroid surgery, vocal fold dysfunction, vocal fold paralysis from other causes
- Distinguishing feature: NO tongue involvement
- Isolated hypoglossal nerve palsy
- Causes: CN XII injury from surgery, trauma, or mass
- Distinguishing feature: NO vocal fold involvement; normal voice and phonation
- Bulbar palsy (e.g., amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, polio)
- Typically bilateral and progressive
- Usually involves multiple cranial nerves
- Characterized by progressive weakness and atrophy
- Stroke affecting brainstem
- Affects medulla
- Associated neurological deficits (facial weakness, limb weakness, sensory changes)
- Imaging (MRI/CT) demonstrates acute infarct
- Neck mass or tumor with nerve compression
- Imaging findings show structural lesion
- May affect multiple nerves depending on location and size
- Progressive course typical[1]
Management
The mainstay of management for Tapia syndrome is supportive care with active rehabilitation, particularly directed toward swallowing function and voice quality. Most iatrogenic cases resolve with conservative management.[1]
Medical/Conservative Management
Acute phase management:
Anti-inflammatory therapy:
- Corticosteroids: Empirically used (evidence limited to case reports)[1]
- Reported regimen: Prednisolone 5 mg/day for 3 weeks (one case report)[10]
- May reduce perineural edema and inflammation
- Rationale: Similar to empiric steroids in other cranial neuropathies (e.g., Bell's palsy)
- Important: Evidence does NOT support corticosteroids as proven treatment—rehabilitation is the cornerstone of management
Swallowing management (CRITICAL component - cornerstone of treatment):
- NPO (nothing by mouth) status until formal swallow evaluation completed
- Speech-language pathology assessment - essential for safe swallowing protocol[1]
- Prompt establishment of intensive rehabilitation program[11]
- Modified diet consistency based on swallowing function evaluation
- Liquid diet modifications (thickened liquids if aspiration risk) - Soft food diet to reduce need for bolus manipulation
- Aspiration precautions: head-of-bed elevation, supervised feeding
- Structured swallowing exercises: Tongue strengthening, oral motor exercises, Mendelsohn maneuver, supraglottic swallow technique
- Serial swallowing evaluations to document improvement and advance diet as tolerated
Voice and communication management:
- Voice therapy with speech-language pathologist (demonstrated to improve outcomes)
- Voice conservation strategies (avoid shouting, loud talking, voice strain)
- Communication alternatives if voice severely impaired (writing, AAC devices initially)
- Voice rest periods
Observation and monitoring:
- Most post-intubation cases recover spontaneously[4]
- Expected recovery timeline: Variable, ranging 3-22 months with median of 9-12 months[1]
- Majority achieve meaningful recovery within 4-6 months
- Serial clinical examinations to document gradual improvement
- Repeat laryngoscopy to assess vocal fold mobility recovery
Treatment of identified underlying cause:
- If tumor, infection, vascular lesion, or other structural cause identified on imaging, treat accordingly
- Vascular lesions may require intervention depending on type and hemodynamic significance
- Infectious etiologies require antimicrobial therapy
Surgical Management
Surgical intervention is rarely necessary in Tapia syndrome given the generally favorable natural history of post-intubation cases. Consideration is given only for persistent, functionally significant deficits after prolonged observation.
Indications for surgical intervention:
- Persistent vocal fold paralysis after 6-12 months of conservative management with minimal recovery
- Functionally significant glottic insufficiency causing aspiration risk or severe dysphonia
- Failed conservative measures including voice therapy
Vocal fold medialization procedures (for persistent unilateral vocal fold paralysis):
- Injection laryngoplasty (temporary or permanent fillers)
- Temporary: Hyaluronic acid, collagen (reversible; allows observation for further recovery) - Permanent: Carboxymethylcellulose gel implant, silicone, GORE-TEX - Less invasive than thyroplasty - Can be performed office-based or operating room
- Thyroplasty Type I (permanent medialization)
- Surgical framework procedure creating permanent midline shift - Allows vocal fold contact restoration - Can be performed under local anesthesia
- Arytenoid adduction (addresses posterior glottic gap)
- Used when significant posterior gap exists - Often combined with injection or thyroplasty - Addresses posterior commissure insufficiency
Surgical treatment of underlying structural causes:
- Tumor resection if malignancy identified
- Drainage of deep neck space infection or abscess
- Vascular intervention for significant lesions
Outcomes and Prognosis
Complications
Tapia syndrome can result in significant morbidity, particularly if recovery is incomplete or delayed. The complications reflect dysfunction of both swallowing (CN XII) and phonation (CN X).
Direct complications from the syndrome:
- Aspiration pneumonia - serious complication from inadequate airway protection and glottic insufficiency
- Malnutrition and dehydration - resulting from dysphagia and difficulty with oral intake
- Communication difficulties - dysarthria and dysphonia significantly impair ability to communicate
- Reduced quality of life - swallowing and voice dysfunction impact social interaction and daily functioning
- Psychological impact - anxiety, depression related to communication and swallowing deficits
Note: Complete recovery minimizes these complications; however, incomplete recovery may lead to persistent functional deficits requiring long-term adaptation.
Prognosis
The prognosis for Tapia syndrome varies significantly depending on etiology.
Iatrogenic Tapia syndrome (post-intubation) - Generally favorable:[1][12]
- Recovery rate: Majority of patients recover with supportive management
- Recovery outcome breakdown:[12]
- Approximately 30% achieve complete recovery - Approximately 39% achieve incomplete recovery (functional improvement with residual deficits) - Approximately 26% achieve minimal recovery (persistent significant deficits)
- Timeline:
- Most clinically meaningful recovery occurs within 4-6 months[11] - Complete recovery can occur as early as 4 weeks in some cases[13] - Complete resolution may take 3-22 months in some cases
- Mechanism: Typically neuropraxia (compression-type injury) with intact nerve continuity, allowing regeneration
- Better prognosis factors:
- Young age - Good overall health status - Immediate initiation of intensive speech-language therapy and swallowing rehabilitation (most important) - Shorter duration of compression - Early recognition and management
Traumatic Tapia syndrome:
- Prognosis highly variable, depends on severity of nerve injury (neuropraxia vs. axonotmesis vs. neurotmesis)
- Associated injuries (vascular, skeletal) may complicate recovery
- Penetrating trauma with nerve transection has poorer prognosis; recovery unlikely without surgical repair
Neoplastic Tapia syndrome:
- Prognosis primarily dependent on tumor type, stage, and treatability
- Nerve recovery depends on ability to treat underlying tumor
- May result in permanent nerve dysfunction if tumor invades nerve or requires sacrificial resection
Infectious/Vascular etiologies:
- Prognosis depends on treatability of underlying condition
- Infection-related nerve injury may recover after antimicrobial therapy
- Vascular complications may require intervention; prognosis variable
Bilateral Tapia Syndrome
- Incidence: Only 5 published cases as of 2016[11]
- Presentation:
- Complete bilateral tongue paralysis - Bilateral vocal fold paralysis - Severe dysphagia with inability to protect airway - Complete dysarthria - Potential respiratory obstruction requiring emergent airway management
- Management:
- May require tracheostomy for airway protection[11] - Intensive ICU monitoring - Prolonged NPO status - Aggressive swallowing rehabilitation once stable
- Prognosis: Despite severity, recovery remains possible; one bilateral case achieved full recovery within 4 months[11]
Factors affecting recovery in all etiologies:
- Severity of initial nerve injury (complete paralysis vs. paresis)
- Duration of compression (longer compression may progress from neuropraxia to axonotmesis)
- Patient age (younger patients generally recover better)
- Underlying patient health (comorbidities may slow healing)
- Presence of structural nerve damage (axonotmesis or neurotmesis worse than neuropraxia)
- Timing of intervention (early speech-language therapy improves outcomes)
- Compliance with rehabilitation (active swallowing and voice therapy improves recovery)
Prevention of Iatrogenic Cases
Prevention of iatrogenic Tapia syndrome requires careful attention to airway management and patient positioning during anesthesia:
- Gentle intubation technique - avoid excessive force or manipulation
- Minimize intubation attempts - difficult intubations increase risk
- Appropriate endotracheal tube cuff pressure - avoid cuff pressures >30 cm H₂O (should not exceed capillary perfusion pressure ~25-30 cm H₂O)
- Consider using cuff pressure manometer to monitor pressure - Avoid high-volume, low-pressure cuffed tubes when possible
- Minimize neck hyperextension, rotation, and lateral flexion during positioning for surgery
- Appropriate tube size - avoid oversizing
- Reduced duration of intubation where possible (consider extubation at end of procedure)
- Attention to patient positioning - especially in shoulder and cardiac surgery where extensive neck manipulation occurs
- Regular tube position checks - ensure tube not advancing with patient movement
- Avoiding laryngeal mask airway (LMA) overinflation if LMA used alternatively[1]
References
- ↑ 1.00 1.01 1.02 1.03 1.04 1.05 1.06 1.07 1.08 1.09 1.10 1.11 1.12 1.13 1.14 1.15 Tapia Syndrome - StatPearls - NCBI Bookshelf. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK567747/. Updated 2024.
- ↑ 2.0 2.1 Lykoudis EG, Seretis K. Tapia's syndrome: an unexpected but real complication of rhinoplasty: case report and literature review. Aesthetic Plast Surg. 2012;36(3):557-559. doi:10.1007/s00266-012-9877-2
- ↑ 3.0 3.1 3.2 Tapia's syndrome in the intensive care unit: a rare cause of combined cranial nerve palsy following intubation. Acta Neurologica Belgica. 2015;115(3):489-493. doi:10.1007/s13760-015-0500-6
- ↑ 4.0 4.1 4.2 Boisseau N, Rabarijaona H, Grimaud D, Raucoules-Aimé M. Tapia's syndrome following shoulder surgery. Br J Anaesth. 2002;88(6):869-870. doi:10.1093/bja/88.6.869
- ↑ 5.0 5.1 Caranti A, Bianchini C, Corazzi V, Pelucchi S, Ciorba A. Tapia's syndrome: keep it in mind!. Minerva Anestesiol. 2022;88(5):395-402. doi:10.23736/S0375-9393.21.15925-6
- ↑ Antonio García Tapia. Whonamedit.com. http://www.whonamedit.com/doctor.cfm/2965.html
- ↑ Antonio García Tapia - Wikipedia, la enciclopedia libre. https://es.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antonio_Garc%C3%ADa_Tapia
- ↑ Tapia's syndrome. The erratic evolution of an eponym. PubMed. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/375880/
- ↑ Cinar SO, Seven H, Cinar U, Turgut S. Isolated bilateral paralysis of the hypoglossal and recurrent laryngeal nerves (bilateral Tapia syndrome) after transoral intubation for general anesthesia. Acta Anaesthesiol Scand. 2005;49(1):98-99. doi:10.1111/j.1399-6576.2004.00563.x
- ↑ Jee CH, Kim HJ, Kwak KH. A case report of Tapia's syndrome after mastectomy and breast reconstruction under general anesthesia. Medicine. 2018;97(32):e11811. doi:10.1097/MD.0000000000011811
- ↑ 11.0 11.1 11.2 11.3 11.4 Bilbao I, Dopazo C, Caralt M, et al. Isolated bilateral Tapia's syndrome after liver transplantation: a case report and review of the literature. World J Hepatol. 2016;8(20):871-875. doi:10.4254/wjh.v8.i20.871
- ↑ 12.0 12.1 Gevorgyan A, Nedzelski JM. A late recognition of Tapia syndrome: a case report and literature review. Laryngoscope. 2013;123(10):2423-2427. doi:10.1002/lary.23778
- ↑ Cinar SO, Seven H, Cinar U, Turgut S. Isolated bilateral paralysis of the hypoglossal and recurrent laryngeal nerves (bilateral Tapia's syndrome) after transoral intubation for general anesthesia. Acta Anaesthesiol Scand. 2004;48(6):756-758. doi:10.1111/j.0001-5172.2004.00413.x
Cite error: <ref> tag with name "Steehler2025" defined in <references> is not used in prior text.
Cite error: <ref> tag with name "Interscalene1999" defined in <references> is not used in prior text.
Cite error: <ref> tag with name "Retrosigmoid2021" defined in <references> is not used in prior text.
Cite error: <ref> tag with name "Postoperative2022" defined in <references> is not used in prior text.
Cite error: <ref> tag with name "CaseReview2013" defined in <references> is not used in prior text.
Cite error: <ref> tag with name "Rhinoplasty2007" defined in <references> is not used in prior text.
Cite error: <ref> tag with name "CaseSeriesMgmt2016" defined in <references> is not used in prior text.
Cite error: <ref> tag with name "Waits2020" defined in <references> is not used in prior text.
Cite error: <ref> tag with name "Silva2019" defined in <references> is not used in prior text.
Cite error: <ref> tag with name "Brotis2023" defined in <references> is not used in prior text.
Cite error: <ref> tag with name "Varedi2013" defined in <references> is not used in prior text.
History
Antonio García Tapia (1875-1950) was a prominent Spanish otolaryngologist born on May 22, 1875, in Ayllón, Segovia.[1] He received his doctorate from the University of Madrid in 1896 and subsequently trained in otolaryngology at several European centers including Paris, Freiburg, Berlin, and Vienna under noted specialists including Marcel Lermoyez and Gustav Killian.[2]
García Tapia first described this syndrome in 1904[3] after observing a patient with combined vocal fold and tongue paralysis following a penetrating bullet wound to the neck. The syndrome was initially described in the context of penetrating trauma, but in modern practice it is more commonly encountered as a complication of general anesthesia and airway management. Reports following intubation first appeared in the mid-20th century, and the syndrome is now recognized as a significant potential complication of airway manipulation and various head and neck procedures.[4]
Pathophysiology
Relevant Anatomy
Anatomical basis for combined CN X and XII involvement:
Understanding the extracranial course of these nerves explains the anatomical vulnerability to injury.[5] The critical anatomical relationship is that both the vagus nerve (CN X, specifically its recurrent laryngeal branch) and the hypoglossal nerve (CN XII) course in close proximity within the retroparotid and retropharyngeal spaces of the neck.
Hypoglossal nerve (CN XII):
- Exits skull through hypoglossal canal (medial to jugular foramen)
- Descends between internal carotid artery and internal jugular vein
- Loops around occipital artery
- Passes lateral to external carotid artery
- Crosses lingual artery
- Enters tongue deep to mylohyoid muscle
- Motor innervation to intrinsic and most extrinsic tongue muscles
Vagus nerve (CN X) and recurrent laryngeal nerve:
- Vagus nerve exits skull through jugular foramen
- Descends in carotid sheath between ICA/CCA and IJV
- Recurrent laryngeal nerve branch:
- Right: Loops under subclavian artery
- Left: Loops under aortic arch
- Both ascend in tracheoesophageal groove
- Motor innervation to all intrinsic laryngeal muscles (except cricothyroid - supplied by superior laryngeal nerve)
Site of combined vulnerability: The retroparotid/retropharyngeal space is the critical site where CN X (or its branches) and CN XII course in close proximity:[6]
- Located at base of skull below hypoglossal canal and jugular foramen
- Posterior pharyngeal region
- Lateral to pharyngeal wall
- Adjacent to oropharynx junction and hypopharynx
Mechanism of injury during intubation:
- Compression against greater cornu of hyoid bone
- Compression against transverse processes of C1/C2 vertebrae
- Pressure from inflated endotracheal tube cuff
- Direct compression or stretch from laryngoscope blade
- Nerve stretching with excessive neck hyperextension or rotation
- Proposed mechanism: neuropraxia (compression-type injury) rather than axonotmesis[5]
Disease Etiology
Tapia syndrome results from lesions affecting both the vagus nerve (CN X) and hypoglossal nerve (CN XII) as they course through the extracranial cervical region. The vast majority of modern cases are iatrogenic in origin, related to airway manipulation during anesthesia.[6]
Iatrogenic causes (most common):[5]
- Endotracheal intubation (direct compression - most frequent cause)
- Laryngeal mask airway (LMA) placement
- Overinflated endotracheal tube cuff
- Difficult or prolonged intubation requiring multiple attempts
- Patient positioning during surgery (neck hyperextension, rotation, lateral flexion)
- Nasogastric tube insertion
- Transoral procedures
Surgical procedures associated with Tapia syndrome:
- Rhinoplasty
- Septoplasty
- Cardiac surgery (median sternotomy positioning)
- Shoulder surgery (interscalene block or positioning)
- Thyroidectomy
- Cervical spine surgery
- Oral and maxillofacial surgery
- Retrosigmoid craniotomy (rare)
Traumatic etiologies:
- Penetrating neck trauma (original description by García Tapia, bullet wounds)
- Blunt neck trauma
- Fractures (skull base, cervical spine)
- Stretching or contusion of nerves
Neoplastic etiologies:
- Primary tumors of the retroparotid space
- Skull base tumors
- Metastatic disease to neck lymph nodes
- Tumor-related nerve compression or invasion
Vascular etiologies:
- Carotid artery dissection
- Carotid aneurysm
- Jugular vein thrombosis
- Vascular compression syndromes
Infectious/Inflammatory etiologies:
- Deep neck space infection (rare)
- Skull base osteomyelitis
- Tuberculosis (historical cause)
- Inflammatory conditions
Diagnosis
Tapia syndrome is a clinical diagnosis made principally upon clinical grounds based on the characteristic combination of unilateral hypoglossal and recurrent laryngeal nerve palsy in the setting of appropriate etiology (most commonly post-intubation).[5]
Patient History
Typical presentation context:
Timing of symptom onset:
- Symptoms typically noted upon awakening from anesthesia or in immediate post-operative period
- May be masked initially by residual sedation and anesthesia
- Onset in ICU patients may be more subtle, attributed initially to other post-intubation changes
Speech and voice symptoms:
- Dysarthria: Difficulty with articulation, especially lingual consonants (t, d, l, n)
- Dysphonia: Hoarse, breathy, weak voice quality
- Vocal fatigue: Voice quality worsens with prolonged speaking
Swallowing difficulties:
- Dysphagia: Difficulty with bolus manipulation, especially with lingual manipulation phase
- Aspiration: Coughing or choking with eating and drinking
- Difficulty with liquids vs. solids (tongue dysfunction impairs oral control)
- Residual food in mouth after swallowing
Tongue-specific symptoms:
- Difficulty moving tongue to sides and back
- Food accumulation in mouth (particularly on affected side)
- Slurred or unclear speech
- Difficulty with tongue-dependent tasks (licking lips, clearing mouth)
Anesthetic history clues:[7]
- Difficult intubation or prolonged intubation attempts
- Prolonged or complex surgery
- Excessive neck manipulation or positioning
- Multiple intubation attempts
- Overinflation of endotracheal tube cuff (reported by anesthesiologist)
Physical Examination
The characteristic physical examination findings in Tapia syndrome reveal the distinctive pattern of ipsilateral CN XII and CN X (recurrent laryngeal nerve) involvement.
Hypoglossal nerve (CN XII) examination:
- Tongue at rest: May show fasciculations or fibrillations (indicating lower motor neuron lesion)
- Tongue protrusion: Deviates TOWARD affected side (paralyzed side cannot generate sufficient force to push midline)
- Tongue bulk: Subtle atrophy may develop in chronic cases (weeks to months)
- Tongue strength: Weakness when pushing against cheek on affected side; patient cannot move weak side tongue tip laterally
- Tongue sensation: Normal (lingual nerve intact, providing sensory innervation)
Vagus nerve (CN X) examination:
- Voice quality: Hoarse, breathy, weak (characteristic of unilateral vocal fold paralysis)
- Phonation: Difficulty producing sustained phonation; voice breaks or becomes breathy
- Palate elevation: Normal (if only recurrent laryngeal nerve involved, vagus motor innervation to soft palate is spared via pharyngeal plexus)
- Gag reflex: Normal or intact (glossopharyngeal nerve and pharyngeal branches of vagus preserved)
- Cough: May be weak or ineffective (loss of vocal fold closure for pressure generation)
Laryngoscopy findings:
- Ipsilateral vocal cord or vocal fold paralysis
- Vocal fold typically in paramedian or paramedian-to-median position (characteristic of RLN palsy)
- Glottic insufficiency (inability to achieve complete midline closure)
- Reduced vocal fold mobility on affected side
- May show slight posterior commissure widening due to incomplete closure
Distinguishing features of Tapia syndrome:
- Ipsilateral tongue deviation TO affected side (CN XII lower motor neuron palsy)
- Ipsilateral vocal fold paralysis on SAME side (CN X/recurrent laryngeal nerve palsy)
- NO palatal weakness or asymmetry (superior laryngeal nerve and pharyngeal branches of vagus spared - key distinguishing feature)
- Normal gag reflex and pharyngeal function (CN IX and CN X pharyngeal branches intact)
- This preserved palatal function distinguishes Tapia from Collet-Sicard, Villaret, and Jackson syndromes[5]
Laboratory Tests
Laboratory testing generally not helpful for diagnosis but may be indicated based on suspected etiology:
- CBC, inflammatory markers (if infection suspected)
- Coagulation studies (if vascular)
- Imaging-directed workup
Imaging
Imaging in suspected Tapia syndrome is primarily directed toward excluding structural causes, particularly in non-iatrogenic presentations.
MRI of skull base and neck (with gadolinium contrast):[8]
- Evaluate for structural lesion (tumor, mass effect)
- Assess skull base pathology
- Identify retropharyngeal or parapharyngeal masses
- Detect vascular lesions (dissection, aneurysm, thrombosis)
- Note: Often entirely normal in post-intubation/iatrogenic cases, as nerve injury is typically due to compression rather than structural pathology[5]
- Preferred imaging modality for excluding structural etiologies
CT of neck (with contrast):
- Useful for rapid evaluation in acute trauma
- Rule out structural causes (masses, fractures)
- Evaluate for deep neck space infection or collection
- May be more readily available than MRI in emergency settings
Flexible laryngoscopy and strobolaryngoscopy:
- Critical diagnostic tool - directly visualizes vocal fold paralysis
- Confirms unilateral vocal fold paralysis in paramedian position
- Assesses vocal fold movement (complete paralysis vs. paresis)
- Evaluates glottic closure pattern and degree of insufficiency
- Stroboscopy assesses vibratory characteristics
Electromyography (EMG):[5]
- May help confirm nerve injury and localize lesion
- Provides prognostic value for expected recovery
- Identifies denervation changes and reinnervation
- Timing: Typically performed 2-4 weeks after injury (allows time for fibrillation potentials to develop)
- Bilateral EMG may be performed to assess CN XII and recurrent laryngeal nerve function
- Can differentiate neuropraxia from axonotmesis based on motor unit action potentials
Differential Diagnosis
The key to differentiating Tapia syndrome from other cranial nerve syndromes is the specific combination of CN X (recurrent laryngeal nerve) and CN XII involvement with preserved CN IX and normal palatal function.[5]
Related cranial nerve syndromes affecting larynx and tongue:
- Jackson syndrome
- Cranial nerves affected: CN X, XI, XII
- Location of lesion: Medulla oblongata or medullary region (intracranial)
- Key distinction: Intracranial lesion; includes CN XI (accessory nerve); palatal weakness present
- Clinical features: Vocal fold paralysis + tongue paralysis + weakness of trapezius/sternocleidomastoid
- Collet-Sicard syndrome
- Cranial nerves affected: CN IX, X, XI, XII
- Location of lesion: Jugular foramen and hypoglossal canal region (skull base)
- Key distinction: Includes CN IX (glossopharyngeal - affects gag reflex); involves both jugular foramen AND hypoglossal canal
- Clinical features: Vocal fold paralysis + tongue paralysis + loss of gag reflex + pharyngeal weakness
- Villaret syndrome
- Cranial nerves affected: CN IX, X, XI, XII + Horner syndrome
- Location of lesion: Retroparotid space (extracranial)
- Key distinction: Collet-Sicard syndrome (CN IX-XII palsy) PLUS ipsilateral Horner syndrome (sympathetic involvement)
- Clinical features: Vocal fold + tongue + gag reflex loss + ptosis + miosis + anhidrosis
- Schmidt syndrome
- Cranial nerves affected: CN X, XI only (spares CN XII)
- Location of lesion: Medulla or jugular foramen
- Key distinction: NO tongue involvement; vocal fold paralysis + trapezius/SCM weakness
- Vernet syndrome
- Cranial nerves affected: CN IX, X, XI only
- Location of lesion: Intracranial, within jugular foramen
- Key distinction: NO CN XII involvement; location always intracranial
Other differential considerations:
- Isolated vocal fold paralysis
- Causes: Thyroid surgery, vocal fold dysfunction, vocal fold paralysis from other causes
- Distinguishing feature: NO tongue involvement
- Isolated hypoglossal nerve palsy
- Causes: CN XII injury from surgery, trauma, or mass
- Distinguishing feature: NO vocal fold involvement; normal voice and phonation
- Bulbar palsy (e.g., amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, polio)
- Typically bilateral and progressive
- Usually involves multiple cranial nerves
- Characterized by progressive weakness and atrophy
- Stroke affecting brainstem
- Affects medulla
- Associated neurological deficits (facial weakness, limb weakness, sensory changes)
- Imaging (MRI/CT) demonstrates acute infarct
- Neck mass or tumor with nerve compression
- Imaging findings show structural lesion
- May affect multiple nerves depending on location and size
- Progressive course typical[5]
Management
The mainstay of management for Tapia syndrome is supportive care with active rehabilitation, particularly directed toward swallowing function and voice quality. Most iatrogenic cases resolve with conservative management.[5]
Medical/Conservative Management
Acute phase management:
Anti-inflammatory therapy:
- Corticosteroids: Empirically used (evidence limited to case reports)[5]
- Reported regimen: Prednisolone 5 mg/day for 3 weeks (one case report)[9]
- May reduce perineural edema and inflammation
- Rationale: Similar to empiric steroids in other cranial neuropathies (e.g., Bell's palsy)
- Important: Evidence does NOT support corticosteroids as proven treatment—rehabilitation is the cornerstone of management
Swallowing management (CRITICAL component - cornerstone of treatment):
- NPO (nothing by mouth) status until formal swallow evaluation completed
- Speech-language pathology assessment - essential for safe swallowing protocol[5]
- Prompt establishment of intensive rehabilitation program[10]
- Modified diet consistency based on swallowing function evaluation
- Liquid diet modifications (thickened liquids if aspiration risk) - Soft food diet to reduce need for bolus manipulation
- Aspiration precautions: head-of-bed elevation, supervised feeding
- Structured swallowing exercises: Tongue strengthening, oral motor exercises, Mendelsohn maneuver, supraglottic swallow technique
- Serial swallowing evaluations to document improvement and advance diet as tolerated
Voice and communication management:
- Voice therapy with speech-language pathologist (demonstrated to improve outcomes)
- Voice conservation strategies (avoid shouting, loud talking, voice strain)
- Communication alternatives if voice severely impaired (writing, AAC devices initially)
- Voice rest periods
Observation and monitoring:
- Most post-intubation cases recover spontaneously[7]
- Expected recovery timeline: Variable, ranging 3-22 months with median of 9-12 months[5]
- Majority achieve meaningful recovery within 4-6 months
- Serial clinical examinations to document gradual improvement
- Repeat laryngoscopy to assess vocal fold mobility recovery
Treatment of identified underlying cause:
- If tumor, infection, vascular lesion, or other structural cause identified on imaging, treat accordingly
- Vascular lesions may require intervention depending on type and hemodynamic significance
- Infectious etiologies require antimicrobial therapy
Surgical Management
Surgical intervention is rarely necessary in Tapia syndrome given the generally favorable natural history of post-intubation cases. Consideration is given only for persistent, functionally significant deficits after prolonged observation.
Indications for surgical intervention:
- Persistent vocal fold paralysis after 6-12 months of conservative management with minimal recovery
- Functionally significant glottic insufficiency causing aspiration risk or severe dysphonia
- Failed conservative measures including voice therapy
Vocal fold medialization procedures (for persistent unilateral vocal fold paralysis):
- Injection laryngoplasty (temporary or permanent fillers)
- Temporary: Hyaluronic acid, collagen (reversible; allows observation for further recovery) - Permanent: Carboxymethylcellulose gel implant, silicone, GORE-TEX - Less invasive than thyroplasty - Can be performed office-based or operating room
- Thyroplasty Type I (permanent medialization)
- Surgical framework procedure creating permanent midline shift - Allows vocal fold contact restoration - Can be performed under local anesthesia
- Arytenoid adduction (addresses posterior glottic gap)
- Used when significant posterior gap exists - Often combined with injection or thyroplasty - Addresses posterior commissure insufficiency
Surgical treatment of underlying structural causes:
- Tumor resection if malignancy identified
- Drainage of deep neck space infection or abscess
- Vascular intervention for significant lesions
Outcomes and Prognosis
Complications
Tapia syndrome can result in significant morbidity, particularly if recovery is incomplete or delayed. The complications reflect dysfunction of both swallowing (CN XII) and phonation (CN X).
Direct complications from the syndrome:
- Aspiration pneumonia - serious complication from inadequate airway protection and glottic insufficiency
- Malnutrition and dehydration - resulting from dysphagia and difficulty with oral intake
- Communication difficulties - dysarthria and dysphonia significantly impair ability to communicate
- Reduced quality of life - swallowing and voice dysfunction impact social interaction and daily functioning
- Psychological impact - anxiety, depression related to communication and swallowing deficits
Note: Complete recovery minimizes these complications; however, incomplete recovery may lead to persistent functional deficits requiring long-term adaptation.
Prognosis
The prognosis for Tapia syndrome varies significantly depending on etiology.
Iatrogenic Tapia syndrome (post-intubation) - Generally favorable:[5][11]
- Recovery rate: Majority of patients recover with supportive management
- Recovery outcome breakdown:[11]
- Approximately 30% achieve complete recovery - Approximately 39% achieve incomplete recovery (functional improvement with residual deficits) - Approximately 26% achieve minimal recovery (persistent significant deficits)
- Timeline:
- Most clinically meaningful recovery occurs within 4-6 months[10] - Complete recovery can occur as early as 4 weeks in some cases[12] - Complete resolution may take 3-22 months in some cases
- Mechanism: Typically neuropraxia (compression-type injury) with intact nerve continuity, allowing regeneration
- Better prognosis factors:
- Young age - Good overall health status - Immediate initiation of intensive speech-language therapy and swallowing rehabilitation (most important) - Shorter duration of compression - Early recognition and management
Traumatic Tapia syndrome:
- Prognosis highly variable, depends on severity of nerve injury (neuropraxia vs. axonotmesis vs. neurotmesis)
- Associated injuries (vascular, skeletal) may complicate recovery
- Penetrating trauma with nerve transection has poorer prognosis; recovery unlikely without surgical repair
Neoplastic Tapia syndrome:
- Prognosis primarily dependent on tumor type, stage, and treatability
- Nerve recovery depends on ability to treat underlying tumor
- May result in permanent nerve dysfunction if tumor invades nerve or requires sacrificial resection
Infectious/Vascular etiologies:
- Prognosis depends on treatability of underlying condition
- Infection-related nerve injury may recover after antimicrobial therapy
- Vascular complications may require intervention; prognosis variable
Bilateral Tapia Syndrome
- Incidence: Only 5 published cases as of 2016[10]
- Presentation:
- Complete bilateral tongue paralysis - Bilateral vocal fold paralysis - Severe dysphagia with inability to protect airway - Complete dysarthria - Potential respiratory obstruction requiring emergent airway management
- Management:
- May require tracheostomy for airway protection[10] - Intensive ICU monitoring - Prolonged NPO status - Aggressive swallowing rehabilitation once stable
- Prognosis: Despite severity, recovery remains possible; one bilateral case achieved full recovery within 4 months[10]
Factors affecting recovery in all etiologies:
- Severity of initial nerve injury (complete paralysis vs. paresis)
- Duration of compression (longer compression may progress from neuropraxia to axonotmesis)
- Patient age (younger patients generally recover better)
- Underlying patient health (comorbidities may slow healing)
- Presence of structural nerve damage (axonotmesis or neurotmesis worse than neuropraxia)
- Timing of intervention (early speech-language therapy improves outcomes)
- Compliance with rehabilitation (active swallowing and voice therapy improves recovery)
Prevention of Iatrogenic Cases
Prevention of iatrogenic Tapia syndrome requires careful attention to airway management and patient positioning during anesthesia:
- Gentle intubation technique - avoid excessive force or manipulation
- Minimize intubation attempts - difficult intubations increase risk
- Appropriate endotracheal tube cuff pressure - avoid cuff pressures >30 cm H₂O (should not exceed capillary perfusion pressure ~25-30 cm H₂O)
- Consider using cuff pressure manometer to monitor pressure - Avoid high-volume, low-pressure cuffed tubes when possible
- Minimize neck hyperextension, rotation, and lateral flexion during positioning for surgery
- Appropriate tube size - avoid oversizing
- Reduced duration of intubation where possible (consider extubation at end of procedure)
- Attention to patient positioning - especially in shoulder and cardiac surgery where extensive neck manipulation occurs
- Regular tube position checks - ensure tube not advancing with patient movement
- Avoiding laryngeal mask airway (LMA) overinflation if LMA used alternatively[5]
References
- ↑ Antonio García Tapia. Whonamedit.com. http://www.whonamedit.com/doctor.cfm/2965.html
- ↑ Antonio García Tapia - Wikipedia, la enciclopedia libre. https://es.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antonio_Garc%C3%ADa_Tapia
- ↑ Tapia's syndrome. The erratic evolution of an eponym. PubMed. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/375880/
- ↑ Lykoudis EG, Seretis K. Tapia's syndrome: an unexpected but real complication of rhinoplasty: case report and literature review. Aesthetic Plast Surg. 2012;36(3):557-559. doi:10.1007/s00266-012-9877-2
- ↑ 5.00 5.01 5.02 5.03 5.04 5.05 5.06 5.07 5.08 5.09 5.10 5.11 5.12 5.13 5.14 Tapia Syndrome - StatPearls - NCBI Bookshelf. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK567747/. Updated 2024.
- ↑ 6.0 6.1 Tapia's syndrome in the intensive care unit: a rare cause of combined cranial nerve palsy following intubation. Acta Neurologica Belgica. 2015;115(3):489-493. doi:10.1007/s13760-015-0500-6
- ↑ 7.0 7.1 Boisseau N, Rabarijaona H, Grimaud D, Raucoules-Aimé M. Tapia's syndrome following shoulder surgery. Br J Anaesth. 2002;88(6):869-870. doi:10.1093/bja/88.6.869
- ↑ Cinar SO, Seven H, Cinar U, Turgut S. Isolated bilateral paralysis of the hypoglossal and recurrent laryngeal nerves (bilateral Tapia syndrome) after transoral intubation for general anesthesia. Acta Anaesthesiol Scand. 2005;49(1):98-99. Cite error: Invalid
<ref>tag; name "Cinar2005" defined multiple times with different content - ↑ Jee CH, Kim HJ, Kwak KH. A case report of Tapia's syndrome after mastectomy and breast reconstruction under general anesthesia. Medicine. 2018;97(32):e11811. doi:10.1097/MD.0000000000011811
- ↑ 10.0 10.1 10.2 10.3 10.4 Bilbao I, Dopazo C, Caralt M, et al. Isolated bilateral Tapia's syndrome after liver transplantation: a case report and review of the literature. World J Hepatol. 2016;8(20):871-875. doi:10.4254/wjh.v8.i20.871
- ↑ 11.0 11.1 Gevorgyan A, Nedzelski JM. A late recognition of Tapia syndrome: a case report and literature review. Laryngoscope. 2013;123(10):2423-2427. doi:10.1002/lary.23778
- ↑ Cinar SO, Seven H, Cinar U, Turgut S. Isolated bilateral paralysis of the hypoglossal and recurrent laryngeal nerves (bilateral Tapia's syndrome) after transoral intubation for general anesthesia. Acta Anaesthesiol Scand. 2004;48(6):756-758. doi:10.1111/j.0001-5172.2004.00413.x
Cite error: <ref> tag with name "Steehler2025" defined in <references> is not used in prior text.
Cite error: <ref> tag with name "Interscalene1999" defined in <references> is not used in prior text.
Cite error: <ref> tag with name "Retrosigmoid2021" defined in <references> is not used in prior text.
Cite error: <ref> tag with name "Postoperative2022" defined in <references> is not used in prior text.
Cite error: <ref> tag with name "CaseReview2013" defined in <references> is not used in prior text.
Cite error: <ref> tag with name "Rhinoplasty2007" defined in <references> is not used in prior text.
Cite error: <ref> tag with name "CaseSeriesMgmt2016" defined in <references> is not used in prior text.
Cite error: <ref> tag with name "Caranti2022" defined in <references> is not used in prior text.
Cite error: <ref> tag with name "Waits2020" defined in <references> is not used in prior text.
Cite error: <ref> tag with name "Silva2019" defined in <references> is not used in prior text.
Cite error: <ref> tag with name "Brotis2023" defined in <references> is not used in prior text.
Cite error: <ref> tag with name "Varedi2013" defined in <references> is not used in prior text.